Are Cloth Diapers Better Than Disposable Diapers?

Are Cloth Diapers Better Than Disposable Diapers?

Choosing nappies is one of the first practical decisions parents make - and it often comes with strong opinions. Cloth versus disposable isn’t about being “perfect” or doing everything one way. It’s about understanding the differences and choosing what works best for your baby, your family, and your values.

Here’s a clear, evidence-based look at how cloth diapers compare to disposable diapers - without guilt, hype, or greenwashing.

Baby’s Skin: What’s Gentler?

Disposable nappies are convenient, but they contain plastics, super-absorbent gels, fragrances, and chemical treatments that sit directly against a baby’s skin for hours at a time. While many babies tolerate disposables well, others experience irritation, heat rashes, or recurring nappy rash.

Cloth nappies are typically made from natural or low-toxicity materials such as cotton, bamboo, or hemp. They’re breathable, allow better airflow, and don’t rely on chemical gels to absorb moisture.

In practice:
Many parents find cloth nappies gentler on sensitive skin, particularly for babies prone to rashes or eczema.

Environmental Impact: Short-Term Convenience vs Long-Term Waste

Disposable nappies are single-use items. Each one can take hundreds of years to break down in landfill. The average child uses 4,000–6,000 disposable nappies before toilet training.

Cloth nappies are reusable for years, often across multiple children. While they do require water and energy to wash, multiple life-cycle studies show that modern cloth nappies have a significantly lower environmental footprint over time, especially when washed efficiently.

Simple habits make a big difference:

  • Washing full loads
  • Using cold or warm (not hot) cycles
  • Line-drying when possible

Cost: What’s Cheaper Long-Term?

Disposables appear cheaper week-to-week, but the cost adds up quickly.

Typical disposable cost:
Thousands of dollars per child over 2–3 years.

Cloth nappies:
A higher upfront cost, but the same nappies can last years — and often be reused or resold.

For many families, cloth nappies end up costing a fraction of disposables, especially when used full-time or across siblings.

Convenience: Let’s Be Honest

Disposables win for convenience, particularly:

  • Overnight
  • Travel
  • Childcare settings that don’t accept cloth

Cloth nappies require:

  • Washing every 2–3 days
  • Some basic routine
  • A small learning curve at the start

That said, modern cloth nappies are nothing like old-style flats and pins. Today’s designs use snaps, inserts, and leak-proof covers, making them far more user-friendly than many people expect.

Many families choose a hybrid approach - cloth at home, disposables when needed — and that’s perfectly valid.

Toilet Training and Awareness

An often-overlooked difference: cloth nappies allow babies to feel wetness sooner. Some research and parent experience suggest this can support earlier body awareness and, in some cases, earlier toilet training.

Disposable nappies are designed to feel dry even when wet, which can delay that feedback.

So… Are Cloth Diapers Better?

Cloth diapers aren’t “better” in every situation - but they are:

  • Better for reducing waste
  • Often gentler on baby’s skin
  • More cost-effective long-term
  • A practical way to reduce everyday environmental impact

For many families, they’re a simple, realistic change — not an all-or-nothing lifestyle shift.

The best nappy choice is the one that works for your baby and your life — and sometimes that choice evolves over time.

Sources

Back to blog

Leave a comment